When researching our favorite beverage for National and International Coffee Days (Sept. 29 and Oct. 1), we discovered that coffee hyped up goats in ninth century Ethiopia and was dubbed a “bitter invention of Satan” by 17th century Christian Italians. Unexpected. Still, the history of coffee surprises us quite a bit less than the taxability of coffee drinks in several states.
It sometimes seems that there are as many ways to tax coffee as there are varieties of coffee drinks — and anyone who’s been to a Starbucks will recognize just how much that is. Taxability can be affected by the temperature of the coffee and whether it’s consumed on premises or sold to go. It can depend on the percentage of taxable food sales made by the seller and if the coffee is sold separately or as part of a combination. In fact, even the sweetness of coffee can affect taxability.
Curious? Grab a cup of the tasty brew and read on.
Sit as you sip. Louisiana state sales tax often applies to hot coffee, but sales of “coffee and its substitutes” are exempt when (1) not prepared by the seller and (2) not sold by candy and nut counters, drive-ins, private clubs, snack bars, or establishments that furnish facilities for the on-premise consumption of the food.
However, this exemption isn’t available to sellers that provide facilities for on-premise consumption, and it doesn’t apply to most local sales taxes.
Drink it cold. Sales of brewed and hot coffee are taxable in Pennsylvania when sold from a vending machine or at a delicatessen, grocery store, convenience store, bakery, doughnut shop, or pastry shop. In fact, sales of all hot beverages are taxable in these venues, as are sales of nonalcoholic beverages. However, cold coffee that’s bottled and flavored is exempt.
Are we having fun yet? Well...hang on to your lids for these next two.
When hot is cold. California sales tax generally applies to all sales of hot prepared food, while sales of cold prepared food are generally exempt. Hot coffee is considered a hot prepared food, yet it’s exempt when sold separately unless taxable under the 80-80 rule (see below) or under California Board of Equalization (BOE) Regulation 1574. When hot coffee is sold combined with a cold prepared food for one price, the whole sale becomes taxable — even though both are exempt when sold individually.
Stay ahead of wacky tax laws with automation from Avalara.
Check out this video to see how Avalara works.
When for here is to go. That’s not all. The taxability of coffee in California is sometimes affected by the 80-80 rule, for which there are two criteria:
- More than 80 percent of the seller’s gross receipts are from the sale of food products
- More than 80 percent of the seller’s retail sales of food products are taxable as provided in BOE Regulation 1603
According to the BOE, “When a seller meets both criteria of the 80-80 rule…, tax applies to sales of cold food products (including sales of…hot beverages such as coffee) in a form suitable for consumption on the seller’s premises even [when] such food products are sold…‘take-out’ or ‘to go.’” This is true no matter the quantity of the sale (e.g., 40 half-pints of milk, or 40 cups of coffee). However, tax generally doesn’t apply to “sales of food products which are furnished in a form not suitable for consumption on the seller’s premises.” And a seller meeting both criteria of the 80-80 rule may elect to separately account for sales of to go orders that could be consumed on premises. In that case, these sales may be exempt.
Sellers that don’t meet the criteria of the 80-80 rule should not charge tax on “sales of cold food products (including sales of…hot beverages such as coffee) when sold…‘take-out’ or ‘to go.’”
If you’re confused, you’re not alone. In fact, California’s policy is so confusing that it’s triggered lawsuits.
Try it black. In addition to sales tax, presweetened coffee and tea drinks are sometimes subject to a special tax. For example, presweetened coffee drinks distributed in the City of Brotherly Love are subject to the Philadelphia Beverage Tax (PBT) — unless they contain more than 50 percent milk (or milk substitute) by volume. Certain presweetened coffee drinks are also subject to special “soda taxes” in Boulder, Colorado, the state of Vermont, and several cities in California. Seattle, birthplace of the Frappuccino, will tax many presweetened beverages effective Jan. 1, 2018 (Seattle Municipal Code, Chapter 5.53). Portland, Oregon, may follow suit.
Coffeehouses have been places to exchange ideas as much as consume coffee since their first known appearance in the Ottoman Empire approximately 400 years ago. In celebration of National and International Coffee Days, engage in a time-tested coffeehouse tradition: swap wacky sales tax laws.